Bradley Stepp was outside his Coplay, Pennsylvania, home on Oct. 25 when, as he puts it, “the yard just kind of disappeared in front of [him].” Water then rushed in through the opening, and the family’s basement ended up with “four inches of water” across the floor, he told WFMZ.
Stepp thought he was covered. He had sinkhole coverage through Grange Insurance, but after he filed a claim, the company told him the hole didn’t fit its definition of a “naturally occurring limestone deposit,” WFMZ reported. Stepp argues a broken water main, not nature, caused the collapse.
Moneywise contacted Grange Insurance for its take and was told: “To protect the privacy of our policyholders, we do not publicly discuss the specifics of any claim.”
Thanks for subscribing!
The insurance clarity you've been missing.
By signing up, you accept Moneywise Terms of Use, Subscription Agreement, and Privacy Policy.
Why a sinkhole policy may not pay
The dispute hinges on wording. Standard homeowners policies typically don’t cover sinkhole or other earth movement damage, according to Progressive, and sinkhole coverage added by endorsement depends on the terms of the policy itself.
That definition can make a big difference. Pennsylvania’s Department of Conservation and Natural Resources says sinkholes form naturally in the state’s limestone and dolostone landscape, but human activities can accelerate them.
The agency urges municipalities to inspect their water lines regularly and suggests property owners learn their land’s history. A damaged water line sits in a gray area between natural and man-made — which is the argument Stepp is making.
Must Read
- Jeff Bezos backs a platform that lets anyone invest in rental homes for as little as $100 — 6 ways to build wealth like a landlord without actually being one
- The tax breaks in Trump's 'big beautiful bill' expire after 2028. Here are 4 moves to make before the window closes
Who pays when a public pipe fails
Stepp says he asked the Northampton Borough Municipal Authority (NBMA) for help and was told none was available.
Moneywise reached out to the NBMA and didn’t hear back before publishing.
Suing a local government isn’t simple. Under Pennsylvania law, a person with a damage claim must file a written statement with the government unit within six months of the injury, though a court can excuse a late filing for a reasonable excuse. Counting from Oct. 25, Stepp’s window would close on April 25, 2027.
The state does allow claims over a dangerous condition of a local agency’s water system, but claimants must show the risk was foreseeable and that the agency knew, or should have known, in time to act. WFMZ reports that homeowners must prove negligence.
Stepp has started a GoFundMe and says he’s looking for a lawyer who will work pro bono. “We’re out of money, and there’s no way I’m going to be able to figure out how to pay for a lawyer on top of this,” he told WFMZ.
But he hopes his case can serve as a warning to others, noting that “there’s no protection for anybody from an event like this.”
If your claim is denied
If your insurer denies your claim, ask them to put the denial in writing and cite the exact policy language it relied on. Compare it with your policy’s definition and related terms.
Then, if you disagree with the decision, you can file a complaint with your state’s insurance department. The Pennsylvania Insurance Department can be contacted through its online portal or by calling 1-877-881-6388.
Documentation also helps. The department’s disaster guide says to contact your insurer right away, take pictures or videos before you clean up and hold off on permanent repairs until the insurer approves them.
If a public pipe may be to blame, notify the water authority in writing, and consider asking a local attorney whether the six-month deadline applies to you.
You May Also Like
- Dave Ramsey warns nearly 50% of Americans are making 1 big Social Security mistake — here’s what it is and 3 simple steps to fix it ASAP
- A single line on your car insurance policy could be inflating your premium by up to 30% — here's what to change
With a writing and editing career spanning over 15 years, Emma creates and refines content across a broad spectrum of industries, including personal finance, lifestyle, travel, health & wellness, real estate, beauty & fitness and B2B/SaaS/tech.
