For many retirees, an extra $200 a month would be a welcome change. It might even give them some breathing room to finally get ahead. Sen. Bernie Sanders wants to deliver that increase through the Social Security Expansion Act, an expansion of Social Security funded by higher taxes on wealthy Americans.
If the proposal were to pass, it would increase Social Security benefits by $2,400 a year, along with changes meant to strengthen the program’s overall finances. But there’s another question: Where would the extra money come from?
Thanks for subscribing!
Retire on your terms — we'll show you how.
By signing up, you accept Moneywise Terms of Use, Subscription Agreement, and Privacy Policy.
Currently, workers pay 6.2% taxes for Social Security on just the first $184,500 of their annual salaries. But under his new proposal, the payroll taxes would essentially restart on individual wages above $250,000. Taxes on investment income would also be increased.
However, Sen. Bill Cassidy argued that this approach would impact workers who are “a long way from being millionaires or billionaires” by burdening them with a 12.4% payroll tax, on top of an estimated 14% that he said would be needed to fund the Medicare for All Act, another Sanders proposal.
“Do the math,” the Louisiana Republican wrote in a post responding to Sanders.
Here’s the math.
Who would pay more under the Sanders plan?
To make his point, Cassidy pointed to a married couple who both work as ICU nurses. The logic seems to be that their combined earnings would be enough to put them over the $250,000 income threshold, triggering a 12.4% tax rate on their shared income.
But there are several flaws in his logic, starting with where Cassidy got that 12.4%.
In 2026, both an employee and their employer separately pay 6.2% in payroll taxes on the first $184,500 of a worker’s annual wages. Combined, they add up to 12.4% — but it’s actually a 50/50 split between the employee and employer.
In other words, an employee would still pay 6.2%, just as they did for the first $184,500.
The next flaw is that under the wage provision in the Social Security Expansion Act, the tax would resume on individual wages above $250,000. Even if both nurses in Cassidy’s example earned $150,000, bringing their household wages to $300,000, neither would cross the individual $250,000 threshold.
Their additional Social Security payroll tax under this provision? Zero.
Next, imagine an individual did earn $300,000. The additional tax would apply to the remaining $50,000 by dividing it by 6.2%, equaling $3,100 more to pay annually for that individual. The employer’s on the hook for another $3,100 as well. The total tax obligation comes to $6,200.
The bill also changes taxes on investment income, which could affect a household’s total tax bill. But Cassidy’s example of the married couple doesn’t establish that either worker would cross the wage threshold.
You May Also Like
- Dave Ramsey warns nearly 50% of Americans are making 1 big Social Security mistake — here’s what it is and 3 simple steps to fix it ASAP
- A single line on your car insurance policy could be inflating your premium by up to 30% — here's what to change
Thomas Kent is a senior staff writer at Moneywise covering personal finance, markets and economic trends. He specializes in translating complex financial topics into clear, actionable insights for everyday readers.
