SPY -5.53%
BND +0.61%
QQQ -6.33%
DIA -4.12%
VNQ -2.75%
GLD -5.37%
BTC -6.66%
AAPL -2.15%
GOOGL -4.34%
NVDA -13.87%
MSFT -3.57%
META -7.77%
AMZN -6.25%
TSLA -8.51%
UBER -7.69%
GS -9.45%
BAC -3.39%
JPM -4.19%
BRK.A -0.98%
COST +0.50%
XOM -0.06%
BABA -3.01%
WMT +0.62%
SPCX -9.71%
DIS -3.58%
F -0.36%
  • Discounts and special offers
  • Subscriber-only articles and interviews
  • Breaking news and trending topics

Already a subscriber?

By signing up, you accept Moneywise's Terms of Use, Subscription Agreement, and Privacy Policy.

Not interested ?

Lifestyle
Man in a suit looks devastated, with his hand over his eyes. YuriArcursPeopleimages/Envato

My son’s ex-fiance refuses to return my mother’s ring after ditching him at the altar — how do I get my heirloom back?

Estimates suggest around one in five engagements end in a breakup instead of a wedding. While jilted lovers once used breach-of-promise lawsuits to seek legal remedies, those claims are now rarely brought, and many states have abolished the laws supporting them. This means failed engagements end without court action.

Sometimes, however, serious conflict can follow an engagement. Let’s say, for example, that Ben wanted to marry Elena. Ben proposed, gave Elena a $15,000 engagement ring that had belonged to his grandma, and the couple got busy planning their wedding.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, Elena didn’t show up on the big day. She left Ben at the altar and ran off with his ring.

Money advice that fits your real life.

By signing up, you accept Moneywise Terms of Use, Subscription Agreement, and Privacy Policy.

Now Ben and his family, especially his mother, want the ring returned, but Elena isn’t even answering their calls. The big question is: What can Ben and his parents do to try to recover their lost heirloom?

The ring may not be Elena’s to keep

Elena may believe the ring is hers, but attorneys agree that is simply not the case.

“The engagement ring is a conditional gift,” David Heiman, a family law attorney and founder of Heiman Law Firm, told Moneywise. “If the bride-to-be accepts the delivery of the ring, and then follows through on marrying, then the ring becomes her separate property. If, however, she doesn’t follow through with the marriage, then the ring belongs to her suitor.”

Most states have laws establishing this rule, although the specifics can vary.

For example, Nikoo Berenji of Berenji Divorce and Family Law Group explained that “under California law, it generally depends on who called off the wedding.”

As Berenji told Moneywise, “If the person who received the ring is the one who decides not to go through with the marriage, the giver can seek to recover it. But if the person who gave the ring is the one who calls off the wedding, they generally can’t demand it back. If the decision to end the union was mutual, the court decides on how to divide the ring on a case-by-case basis.”

In New York, however, the rules differ. As Evan Oshan, founder of Oshan & Associates, P.C., said, “A state statute lets the person who gave a gift in contemplation of marriage get it back, or its value, when the marriage does not happen. New York courts have said fault does not matter. It doesn’t matter who called it off or why.”

Advertisement

Because the rules do differ by jurisdiction, Oshan suggests that “anyone in this spot should talk to a lawyer where the engagement happened.” Online guides also show which states require returning the ring only if the recipient is at fault. However, you shouldn’t rely solely on them, as the law could change.

Must Read

A demand, or formal legal action, could be key

Since Elena ended the engagement, Ben likely has the law on his side and can request return of the ring. However, he may need to do more than just ask nicely if Elena won’t just hand it over.

“What I tell families: Start with a calm written demand for the ring’s return by a set date,” Oshan said. “Keep the appraisal and any photos. If she still refuses, the giver can sue to recover the ring or its value. And do not wait. A ring can be sold or reset, and then you are fighting over money instead of the heirloom itself.”

Brandon Henderson, a trial attorney with HMW Law, also gave Moneywise insight into how the process usually works. “Practically, it usually goes in steps. A written demand, ideally from a lawyer, gets a lot of rings returned on its own, because once people hear the rule, they realize keeping it is a losing fight,” Henderson said.

Advertisement

However, Henderson said if Elena refused or didn’t respond, “the claim is replevin, which asks the court to order the actual ring returned. That distinction matters with an heirloom. You don’t want a check for what a jeweler says it is worth. You want your grandmother’s ring back.”

If Ben must go to court, he must also make sure he pursues the right kind of legal action. “This wouldn’t be a proceeding in family court since the parties are not married. There is no divorce or dissolution. It would proceed as a civil claim with one side basically suing the other to get the ring back,” Berenji said.

Ben most likely also needs to pursue the claim personally.

As Oshan said, “If the parents gave it to their son outright, he is the one with the claim, and he should be the one to demand it back. If the parents only lent it to him for the proposal, they may have their own claim to it as their property. Either way, document the history: who owned it, when it was handed over, and what was said.”

By talking to a lawyer and following the right legal steps, Ben should hopefully be able to recover the ring and give it back to his mom — or keep it for next time.

You May Also Like

Share this:
Christy Bieber Contributing Writer

Christy Bieber is a US based personal finance and legal writer who has 15 years of experience. She has written for many publications including Forbes, Kilplinger, CNN, WSJ, Credit Karma, Insurify and more.

more from Christy Bieber

Explore the latest

Disclaimer

The content provided on Moneywise is information to help users become financially literate. It is neither investment, tax nor legal advice, is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast, research or investment advice, and is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities, enter into any loan, mortgage or insurance agreements or to adopt any investment strategy. Tax, investment and all other decisions should be made, as appropriate, only with guidance from a qualified professional. We make no representation or warranty of any kind, either express or implied, with respect to the data provided, the timeliness thereof, the results to be obtained by the use thereof or any other matter. Advertisers are not responsible for the content of this site, including any editorials or reviews that may appear on this site. For complete and current information on any advertiser product, please visit their website.

†Terms and Conditions apply.