Americans are flooding into Florida expecting 'paradise' — but they're not thinking about this one hidden cost that's only been getting worse

But it’s not always sunny in the Sunshine State. There’s one aspect to the cost to living in Florida that has cast a cloud over the state’s many benefits — the high price of home insurance.

Florida homeowners are paying an average premium of $4,231 per year for insurance, compared to the U.S. average of $1,544, according to the Insurance Information Institute (Triple-I) — and the costs seem to be increasing.

“I moved here in 2018; the insurance doubled by 2020,” Inda Stagg of St. Petersburg, Fla,, recently told ABC Action News.

She says insurance for her 1,100-square-foot home went from around $3,000 to $6,000 per year and that last year she was informed it would go up to nearly $13,000, before she switched providers.

“I have nightmares, nightmares, about the insurance here,” Stagg said.

“People thought they were moving to paradise and now they can't even afford to pay for home insurance,” one person commented on ABC’s coverage of the state’s insurance crisis on YouTube. “It's a financial nightmare.”

Here’s why home insurance is such a pain point in the Sunshine State.

Hurricanes, storms and flooding

Florida’s insurance crisis is down to both natural and man-made causes.

More than three-quarters of Floridians live in areas near the two coastlines, which are acutely vulnerable to hurricanes, tropical storms, flooding and other natural disasters — all of which are contributing to the insurance crisis.

For instance, three major hurricanes have devastated parts of Florida in recent years — Irma in 2017, Michael in 2018 and Ian in 2022 — causing billions of dollars worth of damage and a surge of costly home insurance claims.

The challenge that insurers have faced is that, until very recently, Florida policyholders could take up to three years to file a claim. This led to a phenomenon known as “loss creep,” where claims costs have increased over time, often beyond the insurance company’s initial expectations.

Insurance companies estimate claims costs to help set their premiums. If the actual claims in a given year turn out to be much higher than the estimates due to loss creep, insurers could suffer financial losses, which they try to recoup by raising their premiums.

This difficult dynamic has proven too much for some Florida home insurers. Seven property insurance companies have gone bust since the beginning of 2022.

In February, Farmers Insurance became the latest to announce it would no longer write new property insurance policies in the state, citing “historically high” catastrophe costs as a main driver.

“Housing prices are increasing, and inventory supply and demand, lumber prices and costs of labor are contributing to the increase,” the insurer wrote in a memo sent to Farmers agents and obtained by News 6. “These issues also are increasing the costs of claims, which in turn drives down profitability.”

Sponsored

Get an affordable homeowners insurance policy

The right homeowners insurance policy protects you, your loved ones and your home.

Find the coverage you need at the most competitive rate in your area. Compare quotes from over 200 insurance companies with SmartFinancial.

Compare Now

Man-made catastrophe

Extreme weather challenges have been exacerbated by man-made problems — namely, fraudulent roof replacement schemes and excessive insurance litigation.

Florida is said to account for 79% of all homeowners insurance lawsuits over claims filed nationwide — yet Florida’s insurers receive only 9% of all U.S. homeowners insurance claims, according to the Florida governor’s Office.

Many of those lawsuits revolve around roofing scams, insurers say, where contractors allegedly file fraudulent insurance claims for storm-related roof damages on behalf of unsuspecting homeowners. The contractors then sue insurance companies if they dispute those bogus claims, at which point it would often become cheaper for the insurers to settle.

In 2022, JD Supra, citing the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, reported that $51 billion had been paid out by Florida insurers over the previous decade, and 71% of that total went to attorneys’ fees and public adjusters — highlighting the true extent of the litigation problem.