When Micah B. totaled his vehicle during New Jersey’s first snowfall of 2025, he thought the hardest part would be replacing his car.
Instead, he found himself trapped in a six-month battle with rental car company, Avis, and the third-party toll administrator, e-Tolls, after the previous driver of the car he rented in the interim seemingly stole the toll transponder.
“It must have been an Uber or taxi driver, or someone frequently going through tolls,” Micah said of the mystery driver who racked up more than $2,600 in toll charges to his account. Even though Micah didn’t have the physical transponder, because it was linked to his rental car, and Micah’s credit card was linked to his account, he bore the brunt.
Thanks for subscribing!
The money news that actually matters.
By signing up, you accept Moneywise Terms of Use, Subscription Agreement, and Privacy Policy.
Beyond thousands of dollars in disputed toll charges, the battle to get his money back involved dozens of customer service representatives, endless conflicting explanations and what Micah estimates was more than 80 hours of his time spent trying to recover his money.
“The time that I spent trying to fix this was not worth the money,” he told Moneywise. “But you’re so far into it that you just can’t let it go. I couldn’t let them win.”
Micah’s experience also raises broader questions about how electronic toll charges are administered for rental vehicles — and what recourse consumers have when the system appears to fail.
Neither Avis nor Verra Mobility responded to Moneywise’s request for comment.
A routine rental turned into a financial nightmare
Shortly after totaling his vehicle in a snowstorm on January 19, 2025, Micah rented a Hyundai Kona EV from an Avis location in Bayonne, New Jersey. Because he wasn’t yet ready to purchase a replacement vehicle, he extended the rental week by week.
“I rented it by the week because it’s cheaper if you rent it by the week rather than by the day,” he said. “I ended up having the same car for about three months.”
For the first several weeks, everything appeared normal — until unexpected toll notices began arriving.
The first e-Tolls receipt was issued on February 11, 2025, for $74.27. Because the email landed in his spam folder, Micah never even noticed it. Additional charges followed soon after, including two $4 toll receipts. At the time, none of the amounts were large enough to attract his attention.
But eventually, the invoices escalated dramatically.
Throughout February, e-Tolls issued more hefty charges, such as for $521.85 and $689.96, according to invoices shared with Moneywise. In March, even more invoices sought $450.87, $333.72 and $350.57. When the charge of more than $500 appeared on his credit card, Micah began investigating.
“I’m looking at it thinking, ‘This seems weird. I haven’t been in these places,’” he said. “I looked through the toll records and I was like, ‘I haven’t been in these places; this isn’t me,’”
Micah contacted e-Tolls and was told the matter would be investigated within 24 to 48 hours. But before he received a response, another charge allegedly appeared for yet “another exorbitant amount.”
“I called Avis and said, ‘Hey, you’re charging my card. What’s going on here?’” he explained. “And they basically told me, ‘You have to take it up with e-Tolls.’”
According to Micah, that became a recurring theme. Each time he called Avis, he said they told him to go back to e-Tolls, and each time he called e-Tolls, he said they told him another contradictory story.
On March 11, an e-Tolls representative informed Micah that the charges were invalid and that he should receive a refund within five business days, according to an email shared with Moneywise. But by March 20, another representative allegedly reversed course, telling him the charges were actually valid and demanding proof of his whereabouts.
“It was literally one person saying, ‘Sorry, those charges aren’t yours, we’ll credit them back,’ and another person saying, ‘Actually, they’re valid charges,’” Micah said.
Must Read
- Jeff Bezos backs a platform that lets anyone invest in rental homes for as little as $100 — 6 ways to build wealth like a landlord without actually being one
- The tax breaks in Trump's 'big beautiful bill' expire after 2028. Here are 4 moves to make before the window closes
A rollercoaster ride in a rental car
Eventually, Micah called his credit card company, Discover, to remove his card from Avis’ files, dispute the charges and stop further charges. He also began providing evidence of his whereabouts.
One of the strongest pieces of evidence involved the electric vehicle itself. At the time certain tolls would have been incurred, Micah had charging receipts showing he was charging the Hyundai Kona in Elizabeth, New Jersey. Meanwhile, e-Tolls records indicated the vehicle was allegedly crossing the Queensboro Bridge in New York City.
“I told them, ‘Here’s the charging receipt showing I’m in Elizabeth,’” he said. “’And then 18 minutes later you’re saying I crossed the Queensboro Bridge. That’s physically impossible.’”
According to Micah, he repeatedly submitted charging records, receipts, and location information, but the charges continued. He also repeatedly requested photographic evidence showing the vehicle passing through toll plazas — but he said those photographs were never provided to him.
From customer service to the executive office
As the disputed charges climbed to approximately $2,656.76, Micah escalated the matter.
But the process became even more complicated because he had multiple payment methods on file. After he removed his Discover card from the account, he needed to add another card to keep extending his rental by the week. He had added his Chase Bank card.
“I thought they were going to fix it fairly quickly,” he said. “Instead they started charging my Chase account.”
Throughout April, Micah said e-Tolls representatives continued providing conflicting information, and he received a notice that a refund attempt had supposedly been rejected by his bank because Avis had argued the charge was valid. The decision directly contradicted what e-Tolls representatives had previously told him.
“They kept saying, ‘We’ve refunded your money; talk to your bank,’” Micah said. “Then Chase would say, ‘No they didn’t.’ Somebody was lying because my money wasn’t there.”
Frustrated, Micah escalated the issue to Chase’s Executive Office and filed complaints with federal regulators. But as the months dragged on, he became increasingly convinced that no one involved understood what was happening.
By June, he was calling repeatedly, speaking with representatives and supervisors at both e-Tolls and Avis, and he eventually even contacted individuals connected to the accounting department behind Verra Mobility, the company behind e-Tolls.
“I literally found the CEO and finance people because I was so frustrated,” he said.
A refund appeared without explanation
Finally, during the first week of July 2025, Micah’s money reappeared in his account. Not with an explanatory email. Not with a phone call. It simply showed up.
“No one actually said, ‘Hey, this has been resolved,’” Micah said. “I was waiting on a check because they told me a check was coming. Then one day I looked at my bank account and the refund was there.”
After many months, the dispute was finally over.
But what makes Micah particularly skeptical is that he experienced a similar issue roughly a year later. In May 2026, while renting from Budget in Orlando, Florida, he received another e-Tolls charge.
This time the alleged toll occurred after his rental had ended and after he had boarded a flight home.
“I called them and said, ‘I was literally on a plane at that time,’” he said.
Fortunately, the charge was quickly deemed invalid and refunded to him right away. Nonetheless, to Micah, the incident looked familiar.
“First it’s a small amount,” he said. “Most people won’t notice $4, $5, $9 dollars. But if you’re doing that to thousands or millions of people, that adds up pretty quickly.”
Advice for travelers
Today, Micah documents every rental vehicle extensively. He photographs the dashboard, fuel level, mileage and vehicle condition. He records video during pickup and return. He saves charging receipts and compares toll invoices against flight schedules and travel records.
“Every single bill that comes in after a rental, I read it now,” he said. “Cross-reference the dates. Cross-reference the locations. Keep your charging receipts. Keep your flight information. Keep everything.”
He also advises travelers to check spam folders, where important toll notices can easily go unnoticed. Most importantly, he says, don’t assume a charge is legitimate simply because it appears on a rental receipt.
Looking back, the most frustrating part wasn’t the money itself.
“It was the amount of time,” he said. “The stress. The runaround. The fact that nobody seemed to know what was going on.”
And while he ultimately recovered his money, he worries many consumers never realize questionable charges are appearing on their accounts.
“If I hadn’t read another story about this happening to somebody else, I would’ve thought I was the only one,” he said. “Now I know I’m not.”
Neither Avis nor Verra Mobility responded to Moneywise’s request for comment.
You May Also Like
- Dave Ramsey warns nearly 50% of Americans are making 1 big Social Security mistake — here’s what it is and 3 simple steps to fix it ASAP
- A single line on your car insurance policy could be inflating your premium by up to 30% — here's what to change
AnnaMarie Houlis is a journalist and author with more than 15 years of experience, thousands of bylines and four books covering everything from travel, lifestyle and wellness to finance, technology and business.
