These two types of homes offer different homeowner experiences. If you’re trying to decide between the two, your budget, desired neighborhood and how you’ll want to live in your home will be important considerations.
Here are the pros and cons for each home type to help you make the right decision.
Pros and cons of a house
The term house usually refers to a free-standing (or detached), single-family home. But buyers will encounter all kinds of houses, including duplexes and even triplexes that are free-standing structures divided into multiple units. But for our purposes, let’s focus on single-family houses.
When you buy a house, the land comes as part of the deal. And as the owner of both the land and the building, you’re responsible for both the exterior and home maintenance. That will include landscaping, general upkeep, repairs, taxes and insurance.
Houses are great for families or people who want a little more room to themselves.
With a free-standing building, you’re not sharing walls with neighbors and you have additional privacy.
You also have more autonomy over your property — for better or worse.
The larger your property, the more maintenance needed.
More maintenance means higher expenses.
Typically, single-family homes are priced higher than other types of properties, such as condos and townhouses.
More: Condo vs. apartment: What's the difference?
Pros and cons of a townhouse
Townhouses are similar to houses in some ways. When you buy a townhouse, you also own the building and the land it sits on. However, they are not free-standing structures.
Townhouses are typically built in rows, and unless your home is on the end of a row, you are likely to share walls with other homes. Because townhouses are connected, you will own the land in the front and back of the home.
Some townhouse developments have communal spaces, such as pools, tennis courts or playgrounds. To maintain those amenities, members of the community are expected to pay monthly homeowners association (HOA) fees. Also, the association may dictate standards for the appearance of your home and property.
This type of home is more common in urban areas. It maximizes a plot of land, building up rather than out and incorporating as many units as possible.
Townhouse buyers can acquire a decent amount of square footage close to urban centers. This is a big lifestyle bonus for some prospective homeowners.
Also, maintaining a smaller plot of land will take less time. And you may have access to a swimming pool that you can enjoy without having to worry about cleaning it yourself.
If you’re looking at buying a home with plentiful outside space, a townhouse probably isn’t going to cut it.
Also, the experience might not be much different than living in a condo, especially with the proximity to your neighbors and the rules of the homeowner’s association. HOA politics and policies in townhouse communities don’t always suit all buyers, who might feel a lack of privacy or autonomy over their property.
Finally, because they tend to be built on multiple floors, townhomes don’t suit residents with mobility issues.
The dollars and cents of townhouses vs. houses
While a townhome might cost less than a free-standing house, the monthly fees and special assessments from your HOA can reduce those savings significantly. And what they offer in value can vary greatly over the long term.
The real estate market occasionally takes a dip, but both these types of homes are likely to increase in value over time. The rate of appreciation will likely differ, however.
When you own a townhouse, you don’t actually own the components that can increase a home’s value: the common areas and the land.
Free-standing homes tend to come with more land, so they appreciate in value faster and at a higher rate compared to townhouses.
Because the appreciation is slower with a townhouse, you’re likely to get better resale value on a home.
But one thing townhouses have working in their favor is that because there are typically so many other similar properties nearby, determining fair market value for your property will be more straightforward than with some single-family homes. And if you have great amenities and close proximity to schools and public transit, those factors will also work in your favor as well.
More: Is now a good time to buy a house?
Townhouse vs. house: As a rental property
One restriction you might encounter with townhomes is an HOA restriction on renting out your home. If you are looking for an investment property, it may be trickier to find a townhouse that fits the bill.
If that’s your goal here, shop around to find a townhouse community that allows for that. Make sure to read the HOA rules.
Of course, detached homes also tend to bring in higher rents, so keep that in mind as well.
Townhouse vs. house: As an investment
The value of a house will appreciate faster than a townhouse, but neither are bad investments.
Townhouses can be great starter homes for families who want a little more space than they’d have in a condominium.
Which one should you buy?
It really comes down to what you want as a homeowner. If you’re a first-time buyer who prefers proximity to the city center and amenities as well, a townhouse should suit your needs nicely.
People who place a higher value on privacy and want more outdoor space will likely find themselves happier in a single-family home.
If a townhouse is what you can afford, the limited maintenance is appealing and you find a complex with great amenities, go for it. After all, carrying a mortgage and building equity in a home, whichever type it is, will nearly always be a better investment than continuing to rent.
Get peace-of-mind on your home insurance
Homeowners insurance buys you peace of mind. But are you sure you’re not paying too much for home insurance?
SmartFinancial compares quotes from over 200 insurance companies to check for discounts and help you find lower rates in your area.
Use SmartFinancial right now and stop overpaying for home insurance.