SPY -1.48%
BND -0.02%
QQQ -3.01%
DIA +0.13%
VNQ +0.23%
GLD +0.16%
BTC -9.50%
AAPL -0.04%
GOOGL -3.53%
NVDA -4.32%
MSFT -0.22%
META +0.94%
AMZN -2.22%
TSLA -4.24%
UBER +1.95%
GS -2.19%
BAC -0.10%
JPM -0.03%
BRK.A +0.79%
COST +1.59%
XOM -0.97%
BABA -2.55%
WMT +1.58%
SPCX -1.82%
DIS +0.58%
F -1.08%
  • Discounts and special offers
  • Subscriber-only articles and interviews
  • Breaking news and trending topics

Already a subscriber?

By signing up, you accept Moneywise's Terms of Use, Subscription Agreement, and Privacy Policy.

Not interested ?

Top Stories
Kiersten Messier goes over the paperwork with WSMV journalists. Photo courtesy of WSMV 4 Nashville

Tennessee mom billed $1.48M for her daughter’s autism therapy — about $10,000 for every 3-hour session, invoices show

A Tennessee family’s deal with their child’s autism treatment took a turn for the worse after receiving a $1.48 million invoice, along with repeated threats for payment or face legal action.

Kiersten Messier received the bill from The Perfect Child, a New York-based Applied Behavior Analysis treatment services company. The invoice covered therapy treatment for Messier’s 15-year-old daughter Sophia Finocchio, who suffers from Down syndrome and autism.

Advertisement

“I almost had a heart attack,” Messier told Nashville’s WSMV4 in early November. “You know, I don’t know where this is going. Are we going to court? Probably. I don’t really know.”

The money news that actually matters.

By signing up, you accept Moneywise Terms of Use, Subscription Agreement, and Privacy Policy.

Messier added that Sophia had been making significant strides since beginning therapy with the provider in mid-2025. But the family’s health insurance company began refusing to cover treatment costs.

When Messier reviewed the invoices, she found some startling inconsistencies, including line items showing $10,000 in charges for a single therapy session and $20,000 for one day’s worth of treatment.

Soon afterward, the provider began sending Messier threatening letters demanding that the family pressure its insurer to pay the bills or cover the debt themselves. Eventually, a final invoice arrived totaling $1.48 million.

“It felt like they were after me to get these claims paid,” Messier told WSMV4. Moneywise has reached out to The Perfect Child for comment but has not received a response.

The Perfect Child has some explaining to do

Healthcare experts say providers have a responsibility to make treatment costs clear to families. When patients can understand their treatment plans but have no idea what that care might cost, communication has broken down. That’s the situation The Perfect Child and the Messiers face now.

Brook McKenzie, the CEO of Dallas-based Burning Tree Programs, which treats individuals struggling with substance-use disorders, told Moneywise it’s incumbent on the provider to be up front with clients.

“A reported charge of approximately $10,000 for three hours of therapy demands a detailed explanation of the services provided, the billing codes used, and how the charges were calculated,” he said.

While McKenzie said he wouldn’t speculate about potential fraud without reviewing the records, he would question any provider that cannot clearly explain its charges to the families receiving care.

Advertisement

“The complexity of healthcare billing should never become an excuse for the absence of financial transparency,” he said, adding that health insurance uncertainty should be disclosed before treatment begins.

“Families deserve to understand the difference between insurance verification, authorization, expected reimbursement, and guaranteed payment,” McKenzie said. “Those are not interchangeable concepts. Telling a family that insurance should cover treatment is very different from explaining what happens if insurance doesn’t.”

Autism treatment experts agree that the invoice total far exceeds industry norms. Alicia Trautwein, founder of The Mom Kind, an autism nonprofit organization, told Moneywise that the charges from The Perfect Child just don’t add up.

“For families on employer insurance, the most I’ve seen is about $100 a session, and that’s on plans with very limited coverage,” she said, adding that $10,000 for one session is astronomical whether it was billed directly the insurance or the family. “I can’t think of anything that would justify that number. Most families would lose everything trying to pay a bill like that.”

Must Read

Know these realities when dealing with healthcare providers

Transparency should be a basic condition of operating in behavioral healthcare, McKenzie said. They should also be prepared to:

  • Explain their billing practices, identify potential patient financial exposure and establish clear procedures for addressing disputed charges.
  • Work with insurers and regulators to identify unusual billing patterns and ensure families “have meaningful opportunities to challenge disputed claims.”
  • Ensure families aren’t forced to choose between protecting their finances and protecting their children.

“Families facing disputed bills should obtain itemized statements, preserve written representations about insurance coverage, request explanations of denied claims, and seek independent insurance or legal guidance before accepting responsibility for contested amounts,” McKenzie said.

Advertisement

It’s also a good idea to get everything in writing from healthcare providers before treatment begins. That’s one takeaway Dilpreet Singh has when looking at the Messier’s situation.

The founder and CEO of PhysiAssist Health, an AI-enabled medical reimbursement expert firm in Sheridan, Wyoming.

“Insurance will cover most of it” means nothing until the authorization is in hand,” he told Moneywise. “Many denials come from missing authorization or documentation, which are the provider’s problem to fix,” Singh said. “Don’t pay a disputed balance until you know why it was denied.”

Also keep your own log of session dates and times.

“Insurers’ systems flag duplicate claims and units above the authorized limit, but they can’t tell whether the hours billed match the hours delivered,” Singh said. “Only the family can check that.”

You May Also Like

Share this:
Brian O’Connell Contributing Writer

Brian O'Connell is a US based former Wall Street bond trader and author of two best-selling books: "The 401k Millionaire" and "CNBC's Creating Wealth". His work is featured on national finance and business platforms like TheStreet.com, CBS News, CNN, The Wall Street Journal and Forbes

more from Brian O’Connell

Explore the latest

Disclaimer

The content provided on Moneywise is information to help users become financially literate. It is neither investment, tax nor legal advice, is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast, research or investment advice, and is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities, enter into any loan, mortgage or insurance agreements or to adopt any investment strategy. Tax, investment and all other decisions should be made, as appropriate, only with guidance from a qualified professional. We make no representation or warranty of any kind, either express or implied, with respect to the data provided, the timeliness thereof, the results to be obtained by the use thereof or any other matter. Advertisers are not responsible for the content of this site, including any editorials or reviews that may appear on this site. For complete and current information on any advertiser product, please visit their website.

†Terms and Conditions apply.