‘Something was terribly wrong’: North Carolina homeowners claim builder took hundreds of thousands of dollars in bank draws and never completed construction

“Nothing had been done,” Labelle told Queen City News, recounting how she repeatedly drove by the property on weekends to check on the construction progress of her home — as well as other properties that Cotto had been assigned to work on. “I’m finding this strange and I’m driving out there and I’m never seeing any type of work being done on any of the houses. And that was a red flag. Why am I not? I see all these half-built houses, why do I never see tradesmen?”

Labelle’s realtor tried calling Cotto as well, but her calls went unanswered for weeks. At this point, Labelle claims the bank had paid out another $168,000 in additional construction loan draws to him.

“In between that time when I realized that something was terribly wrong,” she said.

Unfinished work

Labelle isn’t the only homeowner to have reported something amiss with Cotto’s construction group.

Lisa Flores and her family have been staying with a relative as they waited for their home to finish construction — work that went through constant delays before abruptly halting in 2021.

Flores continued to pay out the $189,000 construction loan for the past three years, even though she couldn’t actually live in the home. She finally fired the builder group, Distinctive Homes and Development Group (of which Mario Cotto and Parathazathel Mohanan are named managers and chief financial officers), in January of this year.

Flores purchased the lot from The Lion Real Estate Group — the same company Labelle bought her home from. State corporation filings list Cotto as the chief executive officer.

When Queen City News spoke to Cotto, he told the news organization that the stories homeowners had shared were untrue, but refused to discuss the construction projects in detail.

Lawsuits and complaints

In September of last year, the Flores’ and three other families faced an unexpected lawsuit from Robinson Builders Mart, a builder supply company in Newton, N.C.

The lawsuit named the families and their properties as defendants, and claimed the contractor, identified as Parathazathel Mohanan, bought $132,463.65 in building materials from the supply company but never paid the bill.

The supply company later removed the families as defendants and in October, a $155,189.45 judgment was issued against Mohanan — which he reportedly paid out.

Labelle finally contacted a disbursement agent at Truliant Federal Credit Union and told them she believed a fraud was being committed against her.

“I knew that if I did that, when you yell fraud at a bank, they have to investigate it,” Labelle told Queen City News. “And that did work. And I think that raised some flags at the bank.”

The very next day, framers showed up at her lot and installed the floor system and partially framed two garage walls. But then the crew disappeared again.