‘Alligator projects’: San Diego residents resisting ‘over-built, bloated monstrosities’ popping up in their backyards — why they take issue with this solution to the housing shortage

One recent project on Almayo Avenue in the Clairemont neighborhood will house 17 ADUs in the backyard of a single-family home. LaMattery told CBS 8 reporters that each 441-square-foot unit will have one bedroom, one bath and will be rented for $2,600 per month.

“They're over-built, bloated monstrosities in the middle of our neighborhoods," LaMattery said.

On his website, he argues that these projects — thanks to the Complete Communities Program— will lead to negative repercussions, like placing an unnecessary overload on resources and increasing the cost of housing for other residents.

"My greatest joy in real estate was selling to young people a new home. That, to me, is what the American dream is. This ain't no American dream," LaMattery told CBS 8. "This is an American nightmare."

A breakdown of the Complete Communities program

The Complete Communities Housing Solutions program in San Diego was developed to help address the housing shortage and lack of affordable housing in the city.

The goal is to meet the city's Regional Housing Needs Assessment (RHNA) by increasing the number of housing units within the next eight years.

Some of the strategies the program proposes include implementing affordable multi-family housing in areas near transit and for developers to invest in amenities in neighborhoods, like parks and plazas.

However, residents don’t have a say in any of these developer-led projects, as the program allows for “streamlined processing” and doesn't require any public input or notice, according to CBS 8. This is a cause for concern for LaMattery and other homeowners.

What’s the big deal with ADUs?

ADUs in general aren’t the problem for those against the alligator projects. Rather, it’s the fact that developers can come in and build them without addressing any potential concerns from others living in the area.

Bill Buchwald, a resident of the Clairemont neighborhood, told CBS 8 reporters he was surprised when one of these development projects popped up. He’s concerned about there being less access for emergency vehicles, more power lines overhead and overcrowding.

"If you get high winds and they arc against the building, everything's going to go up,” he said, referring to the power lines.

Others, like John Schwartz, told reporters he was worried about more projects in the pipeline, saying that “it's an exploitation of neighborhoods that shouldn't be happening.”

While these concerns are real, there are some potential benefits to increasing the amount of ADUs.

For one, it can increase much needed housing supply at a more affordable price for those who may find available options too cost prohibitive.

Since the Complete Communities Housing Solutions program is prioritizing areas with close access to public transit, it could help people without cars find somewhere to live that allows them to travel throughout the city easily.

Still, efforts are in place to repeal the program.

What’s being done to repeal the program

According to Fox 5, the San Diego City Council voted in March to start scaling back the program to prevent developers from taking advantage of neighborhoods. The council is currently reassessing its rules before updating the program.

LaMattery currently has a ballot initiative survey to collect the opinions of those who would like to repeal the program, too. He hopes to get 144,000 responses by the end of this summer.