California couple was pulled over by Georgia police and had their rental car impounded — why they say the ‘negligence’ of rental company was to blame for putting them in ‘unsafe’ situation

Avis gives couple the runaround

Wilson spent a week trying to clear up the matter with Avis so she and her partner could get home to California.

"All I kept getting is, 'We can't do anything until the car is returned,’” Wilson recalled. “How do I return this car that's been impounded?"

To add insult to injury, Avis was charging Wilson for not returning the vehicle, in addition to maintaining the charge for the full term of her rental even though she didn’t actually have use of the car because it was impounded.

After that week of getting the runaround, Wilson reached out to ABC7 News, and the outlet reached out to Avis for comment.

In response, the company reviewed Wilson’s case and a spokesperson confirmed that the incident “occurred as a result of a system error."

What’s more, the company apologized.

"Avis Budget Group apologizes for the inconvenience caused to Noelle, and will be refunding the rental fee in full, as well as covering the additional Uber expense incurred as a result of this incident."

Wilson, however, calls the incident a safety issue, not just one of inconvenience or lost money.

"I honestly think if maybe we were pulled over by somebody else, the ending on [this] story would have been completely different."

The officer who pulled the couple over agrees.

"We ran the VIN, the car's not even registered with the state," he said in a phone interview with ABC 7. "You'd think big companies like this, this wouldn't happen."

Stop overpaying for car insurance—seriously

Loyalty doesn’t pay—but shopping around does. In just 2 minutes, OfficialCarInsurance.com finds your lowest rate from GEICO, Allstate, Progressive & more. No calls, no fluff—just real quotes as low as $29/month. Why wait? You’re 2 minutes away from saving hundreds.

Find low rates now

Car rentals and consumer protection

There are a number of consumer protection laws that apply to car rentals, including protections for reserved cars being available on-time and at the right location, pricing for services, disclosure of additional fees, and protecting your rights during damage claims.

To avoid the kind of situation Wilson for herself in, you may have to do extra due diligence when you pick up a rental car.

You can verify the vehicle registration number (VIN) online, read your rental agreement thoroughly, and ensure you hold onto any documentation related to the rental.

The Federal Trade Commission advises car rental customers who find themselves in a situation where they suspect car rental fraud report it to ReportFraud.ftc.gov, or contact the attorney general for their state.