‘I'm going to beg you not to buy this house’: 20-year-old from Alabama wants to invest in real estate — Dave Ramsey thinks his approach is like “walking straight into a razor.” Is he right?

The arrangement proved so lucrative that he’s now considering a career in real estate. He wants to buy an investment property with his uncle.

“I saw that being a landlord is really not as hard as I thought it was,” he told Dave Ramsey on an episode of The Ramsey Show. “I believe that's what I want to do with my life.”

He’s now spotted an opportunity to buy another home (with his uncle) worth $300,000 and wanted to get feedback on this new deal.

However, after careful consideration of his finances and investment strategy, Ramsey isn’t keen on Cesar’s financial plan.

“You, sir, are walking straight into a razor and I'm going to beg you not to buy this house,” Ramsey told him.

Here’s why Ramsey believes this young man is on the cusp of disaster.

Too broke to buy property

Cesar has his eyes set on a potential investment property worth $300,000. He believes the property could be financed at 7% annual percentage rate (APR) via a Federal Housing Administration (FHA) loan.

But his income of $4,000 and recent application for a Veterans Affair loan on his current property makes a new mortgage inaccessible. The bank has already turned him down.

Therefore, to purchase the investment unit, Cesar would need his uncle to co-sign the loan.

They’ve agreed to split all the costs 50/50, including the down payment, but Cesar would be solely responsible for maintaining the property because his uncle lives out-of-state.

Ramsey isn’t convinced this is a good plan. “You’re too broke to buy a property,” he told him. “The bank is telling you not to do this and you've figured out the way to beat that is to use an uncle and do it anyway.”

Co-signing on property has become increasingly common in recent years. One in five U.S. adults have co-signed a credit product to help a loved one, but 18% of those who did reported to have lost money on the deal, according to Bankrate.

Ramsey revealed he lost money for co-signers early in his career. “By the time I was 26, I had over $4 million worth of real estate with a $1 million dollar net worth doing exactly what you're talking about,” he told Cesar.

“I had co-signers; I had banks that I had talked into loaning me money… I was buying property basically with no money and so I was leveraged up to my eyeballs.”

When one of the banks called his loan early, it set off a chain of events that eventually led to Ramsey’s bankruptcy in the 1980s. Since then, the real estate investor has insisted on a debt-free approach to investing.

Ramsey’s debt-free approach

Ramsey has often said that his extensive property portfolio is debt-free. “I'm sitting in one building that's worth over $600 million right now and it's debt-free, just to give you an idea that this can be done,” he says during the call with Cesar.

On his website, Ramsey Solutions, he recommends paying off your primary residence first before buying investment properties in cash.

However, given that the median U.S. home price in the second quarter of 2024 is $412,300, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, this is an extremely high bar for most people.

Ramsey’s debt-free approach might only be accessible for those with higher incomes or other sources of earnings, such as through a business or lucrative side hustles.