Cover fixed expenses first

Olivier Boyd, a licensed insolvency trustee at Canadian professional accounting firm MNP, says you first must prioritize fixed expenses.

“You should be able to make ends meet and make sure all your other fixed expenses are covered,” Boyd advises. “Anything above that, then you're entering a territory where it's probably going to be that you have to be sacrificing something else.”

In addition to using common sense, the general wisdom is that people should budget 10% to 20% of their gross pay for their vehicle each year.

For example, a person making $30,000 a year should probably budget no more than $400 a month after deductions and taxes, and factoring in the insurance, Boyd says.

While this “rule of thumb” can be applied everywhere, it could change in an urban setting where housing costs could possibly take up to 50% to 60% of one’s income. This situation would make getting a car a less wise option, he says.

This sentiment is shared by Brian P. Doyle, president and co-founder of Canadian insolvency firm Doyle Salewski Inc.

Doyle describes himself as a “pessimist” since he expects a lingering “major recession.” People who live in urban areas with enhanced public transportation are better off getting rid of the car expense when possible, Doyle says.

Simply add Capital One Shopping to your browser, and shop like normal. This free tool does the work for you.

Install Capital One Shopping

Budget for unexpected expenses

Getting an auto loan also means factoring in interest rates and your credit score, determining the impact that these cumulative expenses will have on your budget.

Doyle also emphasizes the importance of leaving some money for unexpected expenses in case of the “wheels coming off.” This emergency stash is highly recommended for people with older cars that will likely require maintenance.

Car owners must be mindful of how much money they have set aside for any unexpected health care costs, since car expenses can eat into this reserve.

“These [incidents] are a part of life, and people don't factor that into their budgets, so they don't have the cushion,” Doyle says. “They often budget themselves down to, you know, the smallest amounts.”

Avoid predatory interest rates

While 6% to 8% interest rates are common for auto loans when you have a strong credit score, anything higher would land the buyer in the “risky category or second-tier lending, the most common term we are hearing,” says Boyd.

Americans owe a total of $1.4 trillion in auto loan debt — double the amount from a decade ago — and this is expected to grow further, especially as car prices continue to increase, reports the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.

Many dealerships or independent lenders will be happy to offer financing for vehicles that could result in bad credit for users. Prospective car buyers can avoid this trap and look into bank programs that cater to people who are taking charge of their debt.

Most people don't realize that with the right moves, you can become a millionaire — it's not a question of "if," it's a question of "when."

Read More

Read your documents with caution

While the general advice is to get an auto loan from a reputable dealer — which most likely works with a credible financial institution — Doyle says people need to be aware of hidden costs that can balloon over time.

“There are many [auto dealers] out there now who are still reputable, but there are some out there which are predatory, and that's why people have to be careful,” Doyle cautions, citing certain payday loans as an example.

“We see that a lot in our practice. We get people who are paying 45%, 50%. They're paying penalties. They take out a loan for $500 and now they have to pay $5,000 back.”

Doyle urges people to carefully review their documents, whether from a reputable lender or otherwise, to avoid hidden or surprise costs.

“Is it going to be the interest rate? Is it going to be the penalties? The administration charges? Are you getting less for your trade-in than the true market value? Are you paying more for your new vehicle?”

You can also avoid any surprises by asking, “So, if I miss a payment, what happens?” For example, some deals offer plans where a buyer won’t have to pay interest for a year. However, if one payment is missed, the buyer will be responsible for high interest on their remaining payments.

Beware of negative equity

When asked what leads to people being unable to pay their loans, Boyd points to one common factor: “when negative equity is being passed around.”

Negative equity is what happens when people get a new car but haven’t paid back what they owe on their previous vehicle. Drivers then often end up defaulting, since they are paying for two cars.

“So a car worth $15,000 or $20,000 will have maybe a $25,000 or $30,000 loan on it because the previous vehicles still have up to $10,000 payments left on it,” Boyd says.

Having a manageable loan means knowing one’s limits.

Almost 60% of recent buyers did not conduct any research about auto financing before purchasing, according to a 2019 study from peer-to-peer lending company LendingClub. Research and budget, if you want to avoid being a statistic yourself.

Never overpay on Amazon again

Make sure to price-check online purchases with the help of Capital One Shopping. It’s totally free to use and takes less than a minute to set up.

Last year the service saved its customers over $160 million, and with just a few clicks you can start saving, too.

Download Capital One Shopping today and stop paying more than you have to for the exact same stuff.

About the Author

Dina Al-Shibeeb

Dina Al-Shibeeb

Staff Writer

Dina Al-Shibeeb is an award-winning journalist with hyperlocal and international experience in various news formats. She began her reporting career covering the Arab Spring and its aftermath for a Dubai-based news station. She has since worked in Canadian media, covering municipal affairs in Vaughan, Ont., for Metroland Media. Her work has also appeared at the Toronto Star.

What to Read Next

Billionaire George Soros just loaded up on these two beaten-down growth stocks

This super investor is going against the herd. Maybe you should, too.

Suze Orman says you can avoid 5 common mistakes people make in a stock market crisis

If a major recession is coming, the financial guru recommends some fast, concrete moves to protect your money.


The content provided on MoneyWise is information to help users become financially literate. It is neither tax nor legal advice, is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast, research or investment advice, and is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or to adopt any investment strategy. Tax, investment and all other decisions should be made, as appropriate, only with guidance from a qualified professional. We make no representation or warranty of any kind, either express or implied, with respect to the data provided, the timeliness thereof, the results to be obtained by the use thereof or any other matter.