Some of these complaints have resulted in temporary blocks against DOGE from accessing information based on privacy laws. In one case, a judge questioned why the team needed access to large amounts of Social Security data, including health records, and wondered if a more focused approach could accomplish the same job.
“This is like hitting a fly with a sledgehammer,” U.S. District Judge Ellen Hollander said during a hearing on March 14, according to The Associated Press.
These events have raised questions about the government’s dedication to protecting privacy, and whether or not it has the right to grant DOGE wide-ranging access to the info of Americans.
Executive order
President Donald Trump signed an executive order establishing DOGE on Jan. 20, its stated goal being “modernizing federal technology and software to maximize governmental efficiency and productivity.” The order further states the administrator of DOGE shall work with agency heads to “promote interoperability between agency networks and systems, ensure data integrity and facilitate responsible data collection and synchronization.”
In addition, the executive order outlined DOGE has “full and prompt access to all unclassified agency records, software systems and IT systems.”
This suggests DOGE has the president’s blessing to access unclassified data from federal agencies. It isn’t clear how far-reaching that access has been thus far, and what it might do with any sensitive data.
But many agency leaders and labor groups have pushed back against DOGE’s attempts to access information, freeze federal funding and lay off thousands of workers. This has put a magnifying glass on the actual legality of its actions.
What does the law say?
Right now, the courts face the challenge of determining whether DOGE’s attempts to access sensitive information is legal. There are some laws that control how the government can collect and store data that could aid judges in their decisions.
One is the Privacy Act of 1974. The main premise of the act is to let American citizens know about the systems that exist and the types of data the government collects about them. It also mandates that federal agencies must establish records for lawful purposes only and to safeguard them.
