‘It’s just struggle after struggle’: Minnesotans can expect their home insurance to spike by 15% before the end of 2025, says new study — but many say it’s already happening

But some are saying it’s already happening.

Natalie Beazer, along with her sister, Noleene Counts, searched far and wide for an accessible multi-generational home in Rogers, MN. Beazer told 5 Eyewitness News that “it was just struggle after struggle after struggle.” Then, finally finding a potential new home, they struggled to find an affordable homeowners insurance policy.

“It’s still ridiculously high,” Counts told 5 Eyewitness News.

Their ‘affordable’ policy is around $4,000 a year, which is double what they were paying to insure their previous home.

How extreme weather is fueling insurance price hikes

Minnesotans can expect to spend about 15% more this year on their homeowners policy, according to an Insurify report.

Realtor Amanda Cox Zuppan told 5 Eyewitness News that her clients are already seeing higher premiums.

“We’re seeing premiums double and even triple at this point, and it really is affecting affordability for home buyers … specifically first-time home buyers or lower-income home buyers who are already struggling to come up with those monthly payments.”

What’s behind these sharp increases? The weather.

In 2024, there were 27 confirmed weather or climate disaster events in the U.S. with losses exceeding $1 billion each, according to the National Centers for the Environmental Information (NCEI).

But insurers need to stay profitable, so they’re passing on the cost of higher claim payouts to customers through higher premiums.

The average annual cost of home insurance is predicted to increase 8% to a national average of $3,520 by the end of the year, according to Insurify. That would translate to an estimated $261 over the next 12 months.

But some states, like Minnesota, will pay more than others.

“Areas that are more sensitive to climate risks will naturally experience sharper insurance increases, but even less disaster-prone areas will see insurance premiums rise simply due to the fact that repairs have become more costly,” said Joel Berner, senior economist at Realtor.com, in a trends analysis piece.

“Labor and material costs continue to grow,” he added, “which puts insurers in a position where they have to pay out more for full-replacement claims and therefore have to charge higher premiums.”

From hurricanes and tornadoes, to hail, flooding and wildfires, some parts of the country are becoming hard to insure.

Floridians continue to pay the highest home insurance premiums, which are expected to rise to $15,460 by the end of the year — that's a 9% increase. The biggest culprit? Hurricanes. California homeowners will see their premiums jump 21%, thanks to factors such as the Palisades and Eaton fires. But Louisiana’s premiums are rising the fastest.

However, homeowners in every state will see price increases from 2% to 27%.

What can Minnesota homeowners do?

Mark Kulda, former Insurance Federation of Minnesota spokesperson, told 5 Eyewitness News in a previous newscast that an increase in storms in the state is largely to blame for the increase in premiums.

“All of a sudden, in 1998, someone [flipped] the switch, and we had year after year after year of billion-dollar-plus storms come… Now, we have six billion-dollar storms in one year,” he said.

“They’re stronger, they’re more intense, they’re more frequent, and it’s costing everybody more money.”