Fare evasions cost NYC $1 billion last year — and now the MTA is fighting back. But even if it works, here’s why riders still end up paying for it

Every skipped swipe and unpaid toll chips away at the system’s budget, widening the operating gap and putting more pressure on residents, commuters and business owners to pay the price.

Who's not paying for service?

According to the CBC, the MTA lost money in 2024 through:

• $568 million in unpaid bus fares
• $350 million in unpaid subway fares
• $46 million or more in unpaid commuter rail tickets
• $51 million or more in unpaid tolls

It's not as though the MTA isn't trying to enforce fare collection. During the third quarter of 2024, fare evasions resulted in 38,422 civil summonses — a number that remained high in the first quarter of 2025, at 29,046.

The agency has also made changes to subway stations to make turnstile jumping harder. These include reconfiguring turnstiles and installing gate guards in more than 200 stations.

So far, turnstile fins and sleeves have reduced turnstile jumping by 60%, and stations with gate guards have seen a 36% drop in fare evasions [3]. But that doesn’t change the fact that unpaid fares are still costing the MTA — and by extension, costing legitimate riders more money.

Fare evasion costs everyone

Reducing fare evasion could help close the MTA's roughly $800 million operating budget gap. That matters because the more funding the MTA has, the better it can maintain and improve its infrastructure.

If the agency can’t collect enough in fares and tolls, it often has to raise them to make up for the lost revenue, meaning the people who pay their fares end up paying even more.

In fact, the MTA Board has proposed changes to its fare structure starting in 2026. These include raising the base fare for buses and subways from $2.90 to $3 and increasing the reduced fare rate from $1.45 to $1.50. That might sound like a minor increase, but for cash-strapped New Yorkers, especially those who use the MTA 10 times a week, it’s a big deal.

Fares and tolls aren’t the MTA’s only revenue source, though. In 2024, about 70% of its funding came from various taxes, including payroll, sales and business taxes, according to the Office of the New York State Comptroller. With fare collections down, businesses and consumers are covering more of the MTA's costs [4].

The agency also receives some federal funding each year. But according to New York City Comptroller Brad Lander's office, those funds go mainly toward capital projects, not day-to-day operations [5].

In other words, if fare evasion continues unchecked, it’s the people who live, work and own businesses in and around New York City who will bear more of the financial burden.

Everyone has a role in preventing fare evasion

Fare evasion could lead to higher fares, tolls and taxes for commuters. That's why it’s in everyone’s best interest to help reduce it.

What can you do? First, always pay your own fare. Second, if you know someone who’s struggling to afford transit, help them check if they’re eligible for a reduced fare. That still gives the MTA some revenue.

If you see someone skipping the fare, report it. That doesn't mean confronting a random stranger on a subway platform. Instead, you can file a report with the Office of the MTA Inspector General [6].

Even if it's too late to stop the fare evader, alerting the MTA to vulnerable access points could prompt it to install better safeguards in those locations.

Article sources

At Moneywise, we consider it our responsibility to produce accurate and trustworthy content that people can rely on to inform their financial decisions. We rely on vetted sources such as government data, financial records and expert interviews and highlight credible third-party reporting when appropriate.