South Carolina man cosigned a car loan for his ‘big, dumb animal’ brother-in-law — who is now incarcerated. Ramsey Show says there’s only 1 way out

But now his brother-in-law is in prison and Frank is on the hook for the loan. He doesn’t want or need the car. The buyout is $62,000, but if he goes through a private seller, he might get around $50,000. That would leave him about $12,000 underwater.

Now Frank is wondering if he should let the car go into voluntary repossession. But The Ramsey Show hosts say there’s only one way out of this mess — and it’s going to hurt.

A spiraling problem

Frank is stuck with a $1,100 monthly car payment — but to make matters worse, he’s behind on his payments by $5,200 and the car (which is in Arizona) has gone up for repossession.

“You’re gonna have Dog the Bounty Hunter at your door, man,” said co-host George Kamel. “This is not the way you want to go, Frank.”

If he lets the car go into voluntary repossession, it will go to auction and he’ll get much less than he would through a private sale.

“You’ll be lucky if they sell for 30 [grand],” said Kamel. “They’re going to sell it for bottom dollar at auction because they don’t give a rip and they’re going to put you on the hook for the difference plus fees.”

This is known as negative equity (subtracting the amount you could get through a private sale from the amount you still owe on the car).

Frank has about $10,000 to $12,000 in savings, so he doesn’t have enough money to cover his negative equity, though he could at least catch up on the monthly car payments.

But his wife isn’t onside with that.

“She’s mad at you,” said co-host Rachel Cruze. After all, his wife told him not to co-sign the loan, but he did it anyway.

While it may not go over well with his wife — he might just end up sleeping in that car — Kamel said it’s going to cost his family “a whole lot more than five grand if you do it the wrong way.”

Biting the bullet

His only real option is to bite the bullet and accept that he’s going to lose money.

Kamel said Frank “might as well control the variables here.” That means getting caught up with his monthly car payments and then selling the car in a private sale for as much as he can.

For anyone in a similar situation, you can find out how much your car would be worth in a private sale by doing a search on Kelley Blue Book.

Aside from $5,200 in back payments, Frank will still need to cover whatever remains of the loan after he sells the car. If he’s lucky enough to make $30,000 on the sale, he’d still owe $12,000, which Kamel said he could consider a “stupid tax.”

“That’s the only way out of this that is going to leave you with the least amount of harm,” said Kamel.

It’s also going to be less painful than going through voluntary repossession, in which case he’d owe even more money.