This Knoxville woman has taken her neighbor to court over a 40-foot-long trench across her backyard — neighbor claims easement exists, has the right to run line there

Suing over a sewer line

Riddle's neighbor dug the trench in her backyard back in February of 2024 for a simple reason. He couldn't connect to the city's sewer without going through her yard because of the way the houses are arranged.

The neighbor owns a rental property next door, and when the clay pipes in his yard broke, he asked Riddle to agree to an easement so a new pipe could pass through her yard. That way he could connect the home to the city's system.

Riddle's attorney said that she actually gave permission for a connection behind her yard, not the area where the trench was dug.

But, while she was at work, her neighbor allegedly hired a plumber to run a connection smack through the middle, carving a large, deep trench — without her permission and without a permit.

Riddle filed a lawsuit alleging the easement the neighbor claims he has doesn't exist and that the work was done unlawfully.

She's currently maintaining a fence around the trench to help keep passersby safe and the city issued a stop work order after Codes Enforcement found no proof of an easement and that the work was done by an unlicensed plumber.

Meanwhile, Riddle wants to be properly compensated for all the damage done.

Invest in real estate without the headache of being a landlord

Imagine owning a portfolio of thousands of well-managed single family rentals or a collection of cutting-edge industrial warehouses. You can now gain access to a $1B portfolio of income-producing real estate assets designed to deliver long-term growth from the comforts of your couch.

The best part? You don’t have to be a millionaire and can start investing in minutes.

Learn More

How to cope with a property dispute with a neighbor

Unfortunately, issues with easements like this can come up fairly regularly — and they can often be difficult to resolve.

While utility companies may have the right to come onto your property to gain access to their lines and equipment, things get a little more complicated if your neighbor suddenly needs an easement to gain access to utilities.

In some cases, easements can have an adverse impact on your property value as they limit the rights of future owners, so you may be hesitant to comply. Getting a lawyer involved is usually the best option when you can’t come to an agreement with your neighbor, as they can explain the different types of easements that may be applicable and help you negotiate the terms.

Without a formal easement, your neighbor can't and shouldn't just come onto your property and start making changes. Though Riddle’s neighbor did ask for permission, the way he used her land was allegedly not permitted.

If you're worried about affording a lawyer, there may be a legal aid office in your area that can help.

You can try to handle the issue yourself as well by reporting illegal work to the township and filing a claim in small claims court without professional advice — but since a lot of money is often at stake, trying to get some type of legal counsel is usually going to be your best bet.