• Discounts and special offers
  • Subscriber-only articles and interviews
  • Breaking news and trending topics

Already a subscriber?

By signing up, you accept Moneywise's Terms of Use, Subscription Agreement, and Privacy Policy.

Not interested ?

The perils of IDR plans

That any portion of a decades-old loan could suddenly disappear is in itself a happy prospect, says Jade Warshaw, a debt-elimination specialist and contributor to The Ramsey Show.

“Finally, these folks are getting their money,” Warshaw said on a recent episode of the popular show.

But Warshaw also said that current and future student-debt holders should think long and hard about the implications of dragging around student loan debt for two or more decades, all for the possibility of getting some forgiveness at the end.

After a pandemic-related pause of more than three years, federal student loan payments will resume this October, while interest on loans picks up again in September. However, borrowers will be given a 12-month on-ramp period, during which any missed payments won’t be considered delinquent.

Knowing that your balance will one day be forgiven, it may seem tempting to sign up for one of four types of IDR plans currently available: Income-Based Repayment (IBR), Income-Contingent Repayment (ICR), Pay As You Earn (PAYE) or Saving on a Valuable Education (SAVE).

With SAVE loans, the newest iteration of IDR launched by the Biden administration on Aug. 22, unpaid interest doesn’t accrue, and those with undergraduate loans will have monthly payments reduced from 10% to 5% of their discretionary income. Those who have undergraduate and graduate loans will pay a weighted average between 5% and 10% of their income based upon the original principal balances of their loans. And more.

But with any IDR plan, Warshaw said borrowers “kick that can down the road for 20, 25, 30 years,” and at the end hope there’ll be “a little bucket of gold at that rainbow.”

But at what cost?

Need cash fast? Turn to Credible for hassle-free personal loans!

With competitive rates and transparent terms, Credible makes borrowing simple and stress-free. Whether it's for a new car, home improvement, or debt consolidation, find the perfect loan for your needs

Find the best rate for you

The mental health toll of dragging out debt payments

These days, there’s a better understanding of the psychological and mental health aspects of owing people money.

“It messes up your sleep, it messes up your relationships,” said Warshaw’s co-host, Dr. John Delony, a mental health expert. The choice to prolong student loan payments over decades is a choice to be “miserable and not be fully present,” he said, because you always have a black cloud of debt hanging over you.

It also discourages people from earning a better living, since taking in more money means potentially forfeiting eligibility for IDR.

All of this can trigger stress, anxiety and depression.

“Debt can make you feel anxious, especially if you don’t have support from friends or family or from your creditors,” according to the Mental Health Foundation.

“I know how it feels to not be able to sleep at night,” Warshaw said. “I know how it feels to have that effect on your marriage, the way you work, all the decisions that you make are so that you can pay bills. That’s a load of crap, that’s for the birds.”

The debt snowball approach

When you’re struggling to make ends meet, an IDR plan may seem like the best option.

But if you’re still paying off your student loan well into your 50s, you’ll have paid thousands more in interest than if you’d made larger monthly payments over a shorter period of time.

The Ramsey Show staff touts a potential alternative for those on fixed incomes: the debt snowball method. The idea is you pay off your debts from smallest to largest, regardless of interest rate. You keep paying as much as possible on your smallest debt until it’s paid off, while making minimum payments on your other debts. Like a snowball, once you get rolling, you gain momentum.

Warshaw pleaded with her audience not to rely on the government, which may or may not be willing to bail out debt holders, but to focus instead on being happy.

With that in mind, she says what will bring you peace and give you freedom is “you taking back your power, you taking back your autonomy, you being able to financially self-regulate on your own instead of depending on the government.

“I want you to be free, I know you can be free, I know you have the power inside yourself to be free,” she said.


Follow These Steps if you Want to Retire Early

Secure your financial future with a tailored plan to maximize investments, navigate taxes, and retire comfortably.

Zoe Financial is an online platform that can match you with a network of vetted fiduciary advisors who are evaluated based on their credentials, education, experience, and pricing. The best part? - there is no fee to find an advisor.

About the Author

Vawn Himmelsbach

Vawn Himmelsbach

Freelance Contributor

Vawn Himmelsbach is a journalist who has been covering tech, business and travel for more than two decades. Her work has been published in a variety of publications, including The Globe and Mail, Toronto Star, National Post, CBC News, ITbusiness, CAA Magazine, Zoomer, BOLD Magazine and Travelweek, among others.

What to Read Next


The content provided on Moneywise is information to help users become financially literate. It is neither tax nor legal advice, is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast, research or investment advice, and is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities or to adopt any investment strategy. Tax, investment and all other decisions should be made, as appropriate, only with guidance from a qualified professional. We make no representation or warranty of any kind, either express or implied, with respect to the data provided, the timeliness thereof, the results to be obtained by the use thereof or any other matter.