Why did my car insurance premium increase?

You moved

Most people know auto insurance premiums can vary depending on the state. But even moving to a nearby ZIP code can have an effect.

Your new home may have a higher rate of auto theft. The new location may also have a higher population density, meaning there are more cars on the road, increasing the chances of an accident.

It could even be as simple as your new neighborhood having a higher rate of claims.

Your credit score dropped

The vast majority of auto insurers use credit history in their underwriting decisions. A poor credit score may cause your premiums to climb.

Only California, Hawaii and Massachusetts prohibit insurers from using your credit score as part of the underwriting process.

To keep your premiums low, learn how to improve your credit score.

More people are on the roads

September 9, 2019 Mountain / View / CA / USA - Heavy morning traffic on Highway 101 going through Silicon Valley, South San Francisco Bay Area
Sundry Photography / Shutterstock
Heavy morning traffic on Highway 101 going through Silicon Valley, South San Francisco Bay Area

Though a good economy is good news overall, it can have negative effects on your insurance.

More people commuting to work means more cars on the road, meaning the chances of an accident also increase.

The risk of accidents has gone up

There have never been more distractions on the road than there are today, from smartphones to complex in-car displays. Providers have noticed a correlation between increased tech use in cars and the number of accidents on the road.

There are also more uninsured drivers on the road than ever. Some areas, like the state of Florida, have a high percentage of uninsured drivers, and the costs of processing uninsured claims are higher for insurers.

This may force you into adding uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage into your policy, increasing the premiums. Twenty states and the District of Columbia even require such coverage.

Speed limits have been raised

Areas that raise their speed limits may also raise your premiums. Higher speeds mean the chances of an accident increase.

The highest speed limit in the country, 85 mph, can only be found on Texas State Highway 130.

Your area has seen wild weather

Crashes aren't the only sources of damage that need to be covered. If extreme weather has affected your area, such as a hurricane, tornado or flooding, then your auto insurance premiums may be affected.

Natural disasters typically lead to a spike in insurance claims. As such, providers are forced to raise their car insurance rates.

The odds of severe weather are increasing across the country, from flash floods to hail storms.

Your insurer's costs have gone up

For any number of economic or business reasons, it may be costlier for your insurer to run its operation compared to when you took out the policy.

The company may raise rates to cope because of the higher overhead.

Insurance fraud has become a bigger deal

You might be an Honest Abe, but others may be lying on their applications. This causes insurers to underperform due to inaccurate underwriting.

Some may only tell a little white lie and inflate the damages, while others may fabricate an entire accident.

Either way, as unfair as it may be, you may be suffering the consequences of a fraudster's actions.

You made changes to your policy

If you've added a new driver to your policy or made changes to the primary driver of the car, your insurer will have to recalculate the new risk of an accident.

Canceling or changing your home insurance can also have an effect. You might have benefited from a discount by bundling your home and auto insurance together. By cancelling the home insurance, you lose out on the bundle discount.

You may have removed a car from your policy, too, having previously benefited from having multiple cars with the same insurer.

The big one: You're not taking advantage of discounts

While a surprising number of people stick with one company their whole lives, loyalty doesn't always pay. Auto insurers offer all kinds of discounts and incentives to try to beat the competition.

A company might ask you to install an app on your phone to record your mileage or good driving habits like soft braking and acceleration. If you don't drive much, you may be able to sign on to a pay-per-mile policy.

Even if you're not interested in special discounts, it pays to check around for better quotes from other insurers. Every six months is ideal, but it's essential to look around when your current policy is coming to an end.

Use a comparison site to quickly shop for auto insurance quotes and see how much you might be overpaying.

About the Author

Alex Denholm

Alex Denholm

Freelance Contributor

Alex Denholm is a freelance contributor to MoneyWise.

You May Also Like

10 Causes of a 'Check Engine' Light

Find out what that light on the dash probably means -- and what it could cost you.

$400 Refunds Are Coming to Millions of Drivers — How to Get a Car Insurance ‘Stimulus Check'

A group of insurers is handing out cash after hoarding $5 billion in excess funds.

11 Strategies to Save Money on Your Insurance Bills

Your policies might easily be costing you thousands of dollars too much each year.