How to know if you have too many credit cards

shot of woman from above looking at bill statement / Shutterstock

There’s no right answer to how many credit cards you should have. The right amount varies person to person, depending on their borrowing needs and how well they can manage multiple cards.

If you’re starting to feel like it’s a full-time job just keeping track of what you spend — and what you owe on each card — it may be time to reevaluate your credit card count.

Here are some clear signs that you have too many credit cards.

1. You’re struggling to keep up with your annual fees

young woman holding papers looking stressed
Noyna Nanoy / Shutterstock

The average annual fee for credit cards is $147, based on analysis done by ValuePenguin. But fees vary by card type, with rewards cards costing closer to $200 a year.

If you have the U.S. average of 4 credit cards, you could be paying close to $800 in annual fees every year.

If that sounds like too much or you have even more than four cards on the go, you may want to consider paring down your plastic.

You may not even remember how much you’re paying every year just to keep your credit cards active. In that case, you may find it helpful to go through your records and add up all your annual fees.

If you have a travel, rewards or retailer credit card, ask yourself if you think you’re getting your money’s worth in perks.

That extra cash you’re paying every year may go a little further in a high-yield savings account.

2. You forget to pay your cards on time

Hands holding credit card and using laptop
Ivan Kruk / Shutterstock

If your wallet is bursting at the seams trying to contain all your credit cards, you may feel like you’re playing a game of whack-a-mole trying to pay (at the very least) your minimum payments every month.

If it takes an intricate schedule to keep track of your various due dates, it may be a sign you’re working with too many cards.

Most credit card companies offer an autopay option, but that’s not helpful if you forget you made a purchase last month with one of your seldomly used cards.

If you have more than 4 or 5 credit cards, you may find it challenging to keep track of what you owe and when it needs to be paid.

This can result in having to pay late fees and a hit to your credit score.

3. You’re paying late fees every month

Past due stamp on a bill statement
Stephen VanHorn / Shutterstock

If you’re regularly forgetting to pay all of your bills on time, you are likely losing hundreds of dollars a year in late-payment charges.

As of last year, the Consumer Protection Finance Bureau increased the amount credit card companies can charge you in late fees. The first time you’re late, you can be charged $29. The next time, it goes up to $40.

While your credit card company can’t legally charge you more than the balance you’re carrying, these charges can add up — especially if you have multiple cards on the go.

If you’re paying late fees every month either because you’ve completely missed the payment deadline or because you’re paying less than the minimum amount, it may be a sign you have too many cards.

4. You have a high debt-to-income ratio

Debt vs Income text written on glass jar. Business or Financial concept.
arfa adam / Shutterstock

Your debt-to-income ratio (DTI) is a tool lenders use to evaluate your ability to take on more debt. Essentially, this figure compares your monthly debt payments against your gross monthly income.

When you have a high DTI (higher than 43%), that tells lenders you’ll likely have a harder time keeping up with your monthly payments.

This elevates your risk as a borrower and makes you less likely to be approved for loans or approved for other credit cards in the future.

If you plan to apply for a mortgage loan down the line, lenders may look at both the balances you’re currently carrying on your credit cards and your card limits to get a sense of the worst-case scenario.

Just cutting back on the number of cards you have open may be all you need to lower your risk as a borrower.

5. Your credit utilization is high

close up of woman's hands holding multiple credit cards fanned out
Bacho / Shutterstock

There are five factors that influence your credit score, but credit utilization accounts for almost one-third of your score.

You can calculate your utilization by taking your total debt and dividing it by the amount of credit you have access to. So if you have three credit cards with limits of $5,000, $2,500 and $7,500 and you’re carrying a balance of $5,000 between them, your credit utilization is 33%.

The more credit you have, the more inclined you’ll be to use it. And when you spread out your spending over a handful of different credit cards, it can be easy not to notice your credit utilization ticking upwards.

Minimizing your number of credit cards can help you keep your credit utilization in check.

The general rule is to keep your utilization below 30%. Some experts recommend you keep it at 10% if you want an even better credit score.

6. You’re charging more than you can pay off

Moment of payment with a credit card through terminal.monochrome
WStudio / Shutterstock

Credit cards make it so easy: It just takes a tap, swipe or pin code to make a purchase. But if you’re consistently racking up charges without accounting for where the funds will come from, the balance on your monthly statement may shock you.

And if that’s happening with multiple credit cards, it won’t be long before you find yourself in hot water. This is especially true if we’re talking about rewards cards, which tend to have higher interest rates than traditional credit cards.

Cutting back on the number of cards in your wallet can help reduce the temptation to spend. And not spreading out your usage over too many cards can help you keep better track of your spending.

7. Banks are closing your accounts due to inactivity

Do you have cards you don’t even use at all? Maybe you signed up for a few new customer promotions and then put the card away to use for emergencies that never came.

But those credit cards you put on the shelf may not be as helpful as you think.

In fact, you may be harming your credit score. Many consumers may not realize that credit card activity is another important factor that will be used to determine your overall score.

With credit cards you don’t use or check often, you also face a risk of not noticing fraudulent charges or missing their annual fees being added to your balance.

Your best option is to close unused cards before the issuer does it for you.

A better way to deal with your debt

Happy looking couple sitting at kitchen table and looking at each other while holding bills
Rido / Shutterstock

If you want to close down a few credit card accounts, but you don’t have the funds to pay them off, you may want to consider debt consolidation.

With credit cards, it can be hard to get out of the cycle of debt because they tend to have comparatively high interest rates compared to other borrowing options.

A personal loan with a lower interest rate may be just what you need to get rid of your credit card debt.

About the Author

Sigrid Forberg

Sigrid Forberg

Staff Writer

Sigrid is a staff writer with MoneyWise. Before joining the team, she worked for a B2B publication in the hardware and home improvement industry and ran an internal employee magazine for the federal government. As a graduate of the Carleton University Journalism program, she takes pride in telling informative, engaging and compelling stories.

You May Also Like

Looking to Protect Your Portfolio Against Inflation? Don’t Overlook Farmland

As a commodity-producing asset, farmland is an excellent hedge against inflation.

Do Big Stores Save You the Most? We Price-Check Our Shopping List

With one 30-second trick, we found $460 in savings beyond Walmart and Amazon.

Here’s How to Find Better Deals When You Shop Online

There’s an easy way to automatically scan for lower prices, and it’s totally free.